Wide screen devices may view this page better by clicking here

11 November 2020

Facebook   Twitter

Join the Socialist Party Join us today!

Printable version Printable version

Facebook   Twitter

USA: After the polarised elections - what way forward for the working class?

  (Click to enlarge)

Robert Bechert, Committee for a Workers' International (CWI)

In the US, and around the world, millions greeted Trump's defeat in the US elections. His probable removal from office, notwithstanding his legal claims, will be widely welcomed.

Clearly, there will be changes within the US and international repercussions - although many of the US foreign policy changes will be in trying to act more closely with traditional US allies than in fundamental policy shifts, for example in dealing with the Chinese regime.

While Trump's defeat was welcomed, the limits of Biden's victory were clear. Despite his huge vote there was no 'blue wave'. And it was not just Biden's but also Trump's vote that soared in the polarised election. The Republicans can, depending on January's special election in Georgia, hold the Senate and, in this election, made gains in the House of Representatives.

As the Independent Socialist Group in the US, co-thinkers of the Socialist Party, explained: "Biden mostly ran against Trump rather than for meaningful policies". A result was that in some areas there was less motivation to vote.

The New York Times reported that in key cities in 'swing states' like Detroit, Milwaukee and Philadelphia, the "dynamic" was that "Mr Biden won an overwhelming share of the city but did not improve much over Mrs Clinton [who contested the 2016 election]. And in wards of the city with majority black populations, fewer voters cast their votes for him than they did for her... Mr Biden also appeared to do worse against Mr Trump in city wards with a large number of Latino voters."


Of course, the results were another demonstration of the undemocratic character of the US political system, beginning with the fact that in some states there are deliberate obstacles to even being allowed to cast a vote.

Biden's vote was mainly an anti-Trump one. Earlier this year, before Obama and others acted to save his nomination campaign, Biden was trailing in the primaries. He was rightly seen as a typical representative of pro-big business Democrats and a long-term 'Washington insider'. Indeed, in June 2019, Biden said at a New York fundraiser that he would not "demonise" the rich and promised that "no one's standard of living will change, nothing would fundamentally change".

At this gathering, Biden went on to talk about his ability to work with segregationists like former Senators Eastland and Talmadge, showing that he could "bring people together"!

Nevertheless, hopes have been raised by Biden's victory, but even bigger hopes were raised by Obama's 2008 victory when he succeeded George W Bush. However, Obama was followed by Trump, and a question now is, who will follow Biden? The fact is a Biden presidency could lead to such renewed disappointment that a right-wing populist can build upon Trump's 70-million-plus voters and win the next election in 2024.

Probably, Trump doesn't expect to win the legal cases he has launched to challenge the election result. While his legal action is at least partially motivated by personal pride, there is a more important political aspect - namely, keeping his voting base together for a comeback in 2024, possibly by himself, or a member of his family, or another right populist when Biden disappoints.

There are reports that Trump is about to launch a 'leadership political action committee', a legal body that individuals can donate up to $5,000 a year to, as a vehicle for future campaigning.

Trump's populism

Certainly, Trump has the potential to organise his own personal base. Last month, a poll showed that 58% of Republicans and Republican-leaning independents considered themselves supporters of Trump rather than the Republican Party.

Trump and Co's post-election populist rhetoric aims at keeping his base mobilised by saying that the election was by "big money, the elite, the tech companies... who think you are deplorable".

Of course, vote rigging has a long history in the US. For years, the Republicans have been striving to enforce voter 'suppression', ie preventing people voting. But the same applies to the Democrats. The 19th century Democratic political machine in New York gave birth to the phrase 'Tammany Hall' - a byword for corruption and rigging, while in the southern states the Democratic leaders enforced racist 'Jim Crow' laws (which enforced segregation).

And it's not just history. In 2016, the Democrats in New York City removed over 125,000 from the voting register so that they couldn't vote for Bernie Sanders in the Democratic primary, and this year, forced the Howie Hawkins/Angela Walker Green Party campaign off the ballot paper in some states.

The situation in the USA is complex, exhibiting progressive and reactionary features. Trump and Co campaigned against "socialism" both in reaction to the widespread interest in socialism among young people in the US and, simultaneously, to exploit the hostility to the Cuban and Venezuelan regimes among some Latinos.

This latter campaign helped Trump increase his vote by over one million in Florida and get over 51% of the vote there. But this was not a mass vote for reaction. Simultaneously, 60.8% of people in Florida voted for a state-wide increase in the minimum wage to $15 an hour.

Nationally, notwithstanding Trump and the Republicans hostile campaigning, a Fox News exit poll showed 72% of voters favour switching to a government-run healthcare plan, while 71% believed that the landmark Supreme Court 'Roe v Wade' ruling, which helped legalise abortion, should remain as it is.

Deep economic crisis

This shows how, in reaction to the deep economic and social crisis affecting the US, there is a widespread idea that things can't go on in the same direction. Years of stagnating or falling living standards for workers and sections of the middle class have produced disenchantment and, among some, a search for change.

This has been reflected in the massive increase in interest in socialism, including the support that left-leaning Sanders got in his 2016 and 2020 presidential election nomination campaigns.

Fearing that disappointment with Biden will strengthen the search for an alternative, sections of the Democratic Party leadership almost immediately began attacking the 'left' for the party's poor election showing, a blatant attempt to shift blame and also a pre-emptive strike to secure their position.

As President, Biden will be put to the test and found wanting - increasingly he will try to use the threat of Trump as a scarecrow. On this basis, Biden and the Democratic leadership will try to strike 'across the aisles' deals with at least some Republicans.

If the Republicans retain control of the Senate, Biden and Co will say there is no alternative if they want to get anything done. Even before election day, Biden was hinting that he was open to appointing Republicans to his cabinet, something Obama did four times during his presidency.

This is not accidental. The Democrats are a capitalist party, like the Republicans. Biden himself represents the so-called 'Washington consensus', the set of capitalist, often neoliberal, policies that were enforced in many countries from the 1980s until the 2008-9 economic crisis.

Thomas Frank, a US commentator, wrote: "Biden personally played a leading role in many of the signature initiatives of the era: Nafta-style trade agreements, lucrative favours for banks, tough-on-crime measures, proposed cuts to social security...

"Bill Clinton's welfare reform initiative was in fact a capitulation to racist tropes and brought about an explosion in extreme poverty. The great prison crackdown of 1994 was another step in cementing the New Jim Crow. And the biggest shortcoming of Obama's Affordable Care Act - leaving people's health insurance tied to their employer - has become painfully obvious in this era of mass unemployment and mass infection...

"It is no coincidence that, as Democrats pursued their professional-class 'third way', Republicans became ever bolder in their preposterous claim to be a 'workers' party' representing the aspirations of ordinary people."

Working-class force

Experience shows that the 'lesser evil' argument (ie better Biden than Trump) is, at best, short-termist and, more importantly, obscures the question of starting the work now to win support for an independent, working-class based force that can defend living standards and pose the urgent necessity for a socialist alternative.

Even more than ever, there is the need for such a party that can pose an alternative, oppose all forms of oppression, and build a united struggle.

This is linked to the question of how to oppose and weaken the threat of right populism. Attempts need to be made to try to make inroads into those workers who voted for Trump, some of who had voted for Obama in 2008.

It means especially looking towards those who supported Trump because he appeared to be outside the ruling elite, without making any concessions to those racists who supported him.

In his nomination campaign, Sanders partially raised this, but then threw it away when he capitulated to the Democratic leadership in both 2016 and this year.

Sanders himself has a big responsibility for what has happened. It is now decades since he moved away from supporting the idea of forming a Labor party in the US. In doing so, he blocked opportunities to start to seriously build one.

Sanders has twice gathered mass support in the last five years, and yet at both times turned his supporters towards supporting the Democrats, a party which offers no alternative to capitalism.

A new force is above all necessary. Alongside clarity that the Democratic Party offers no way forward for working people or socialists, it needs to have a clear programme, with democratic and socialist demands.

Such a programme would be an alternative, not only to capitalism, but also to the individualist solutions proposed by both the supporters of 'identity politics' and the demagogy of the right-populists. Even Trump's vote is unstable; those who see that he is not an 'outsider' to capitalism could be won to socialist ideas.

The creation of such a movement is already being prepared in the experiences of the struggles and protests that have rocked the US recently. The Black Lives Matter protests, the recent wave of workers' strikes, the women's demonstrations, the different protests against Trump and his policies, and the increased election turnout, all show the potential.

New struggles will drive events. The challenge facing socialists is to build the forces that can help lay the basis for a movement that will transform society, both in the US and, given the US's international position, worldwide.

Donate to the Socialist Party

Finance appeal

The coronavirus crisis has laid bare the class character of society in numerous ways. It is making clear to many that it is the working class that keeps society running, not the CEOs of major corporations.

The results of austerity have been graphically demonstrated as public services strain to cope with the crisis.

The government has now ripped up its 'austerity' mantra and turned to policies that not long ago were denounced as socialist. But after the corona crisis, it will try to make the working class pay for it, by trying to claw back what has been given.

Inevitably, during the crisis we have not been able to sell the Socialist and raise funds in the ways we normally would.

We therefore urgently appeal to all our viewers to click here to donate to our Fighting Fund.

Please donate here.

All payments are made through a secure server.

My donation


Your message: 


In The Socialist 11 November 2020:


Capitalists vs working class - not in it together

Tory U-turn: Free school meals

Tory U-turn: Furlough extended - not enough to save jobs

Covid and poverty rising - Welsh lockdown ends with little progress

Covid law used against striking workers - for workers' control of safety measures

Schools need union action for safety

US election

After the polarised elections - what way forward?

Trump out! But mass workers' struggle needed

Trump is out - our readers react


Spycops inquiry : why the capitalist state feared and continues to fear socialism

Workplace news

Rolls-Royce: Lancashire workers' strike shows the way to fight aerospace cuts and job losses

RMT union AGM votes to defend union democracy

Sainsbury's and Argos: Closures, cuts and soaring sales

Fight the witch-hunt of Corbyn and his supporters


Donate to the Socialism 2020 appeal now!

Solidarity with Manchester students - fight for democratic control of campus safety

Southampton trade unionists demand: "We won't pay for Covid"

Labour movement conference to defend Corbyn and discuss new party

The struggle for a new mass workers' party

Selling the Socialist

Review and readers' opinion

Trotsky's ideas live on in the CWI

The Socialist Inbox

Readers of the Socialist react to effects of lockdown


Home   |   The Socialist 11 November 2020   |   Join the Socialist Party

Subscribe   |   Donate   |   Audio  |   PDF  |   ebook

Related links:


triangleBiden's policies will not solve underlying US crisis

triangleUSA: cop killings and the anti-racist movement

triangleUSA in crisis - the need for a socialist alternative

triangleNews in brief

triangleTrump out! But mass workers' struggle needed

Working class:

triangleRight-wing Partido Popular wins Madrid elections - a warning to the working class

triangleHartlepool sums up Labour crisis

triangleColombia: Mass trade union-led protests force tax retreat

triangleWest London Socialist Party: How can the working class change things?


triangleSocialist Party national meeting: Perspectives for socialism after the elections

triangleTUSC is back

triangleLeeds Socialist Party: The May elections - and the need for a new mass workers' party


triangleIs Biden offering a new 'New Deal'?

triangleEast London Socialist Party: Trump, Biden and the storming of the Capitol


triangleSuperpowers' tensions continue to ratchet up


triangleRMT: Militant industrial and political strategy must be fought for


triangleTrump, coronavirus, capitalism, and the presidential race

Republican Party:

triangleUS in crisis - need for a mass workers' party and socialist programme

Black Lives Matter:

triangleWelsh Labour holds on to government but new crises loom


triangleStop war on Gaza demo, London 15.5.21. Socialist Party members were at the many protests across Britain

Article dated 11 November 2020

Join the Socialist Party
Subscribe to Socialist Party publications
Donate to the Socialist Party


Pay in Fighting Fund

Pay in paper and book sales


Bulk book orders

New member submission


triangle17 May Oxfordshire & Aylesbury Socialist Party: The role of the state

triangle18 May Bristol North Socialist Party: Liverpool - history of socialist struggle

triangle19 May North London Socialist Party: Stop the Gaza slaughter - How can the conflict be ended?


The Socialist, weekly newspaper of the Socialist Party

Election analysis


International news

Workplace news

Readers' opinion


Subscribespacer|spacerebook / Kindlespacer|spacerPDF versionspacer|spacerText / Printspacer|spacer1133 onlinespacer|spacerBack issuesspacer|spacer Audio files

Stop war on Gaza demo, London 15th May 2021

Stop war on Gaza demo, London 15.5.21. Socialist Party members were at the many protests across Britain

What We Stand For
Socialist Party Facebook page
Socialist Party on Twitter
Visit us on Youtube

Platform setting: =

Desktop version